Skip to the reading

Washington Auto Claims: Eight Rights Consumers Can Use After a Crash

Electric Vehicles Teresa Moss 585 reads

A revised handout outlines Washington drivers’ rights to inspections, written claim decisions, file records and an appraisal process.

Washington Auto Claims: Eight Rights Consumers Can Use After a Crash

For Washington drivers dealing with a disputed repair estimate, the practical value of the state’s updated claims rules lies in the steps they make available: request an in-person inspection, ask for written reasons behind a payment decision, and get certain claim records. Collision Consulting, an appraisal and investigations company owned by Jeff Butler, has revised a consumer handout to explain eight rights available to people handling auto claims.

The changes took effect Oct. 18. The handout collects requirements that affect how insurers evaluate damage, respond to repair documents and share claim information. Its central message for drivers is to keep the repair facility involved, make requests clearly and seek written explanations when an estimate or invoice is challenged.

Repair choice and inspections

Consumers have the right to choose a repair facility. The handout says an insurer may not unreasonably reject that facility’s estimate. If the insurer pays less, it must promptly disclose its reasons, explain the policy basis for rejecting the estimate or invoice, and record the decision in its claim file.

That gives a driver a concrete basis for understanding a difference between the shop’s proposed repair cost and the insurer’s evaluation. A useful next step is to ask for the specific items in dispute and the reasoning behind each one, rather than relying on a general explanation of the total payment.

A photo-based estimate also does not have to settle the question when the damage or amount of loss is disputed. If the insurer used a virtual inspection, the consumer can request an in-person inspection. Under the handout, the insurer must complete that inspection within five business days unless the parties agree to a different time.

That option matters because a vehicle’s visible damage may not show every issue relevant to the repair. An in-person review gives the insurer and repair facility another opportunity to assess the vehicle when their views of the damage differ. The handout’s stated timeframe gives consumers a specific response period to track after making the request.

Written decisions on repair work and costs

Insurers must respond to supplements and final invoices within five business days, according to the handout. The response must be in writing and go to both the claimant and the repair facility. It must identify the insurer’s decision about covered amounts, and rejected items must be connected to the relevant policy language, the facts of the loss, or both.

Consumers can also ask the insurer to explain in writing how it determined labor and material costs and the repair processes used in its evaluation. If the insurer relies on a database, survey, estimating system or benchmark to set labor or material prices, the handout recommends requesting the date of the data, its geographic source and the businesses that supplied it. It also says a reasonable investigation cannot rely only on a database.

For drivers, the value of that detail is straightforward: it helps show what assumptions sit behind an estimate and where the insurer’s numbers came from. The handout does not say that a requested explanation will resolve every disagreement, but it gives claimants a way to ask for the basis of the evaluation and compare it with the repair facility’s findings.

Communication, evaluations and claim records

A consumer may ask to be included in all communications between the insurer and the repair shop. The insurer must also allow claim information to be delivered by email, mail, fax or in person. Keeping the claimant copied can make it easier to follow decisions about the repair and identify questions while the shop and insurer are discussing the work.

The insurer remains responsible for the accuracy of its evaluation and repair documentation. Estimates must be prepared by someone with the relevant expertise, training and experience to assess the damaged vehicle. The insurer must consider additional damage related to the loss when the claimant or repair facility discovers it. The handout also reiterates that an investigation cannot rely solely on databases.

First-party insureds may request parts of their claim file, including estimates, notes, reports, photographs and communications. The insurer has 15 business days to provide the requested documents. Those records can help a claimant understand how the evaluation developed and what information informed the decision.

Claims investigations generally must be completed within 30 calendar days. If an investigation takes longer, the insurer must give written reasons and continue providing updates every 30 days. For a driver managing a claim, these deadlines offer reference points for following up and documenting when requests and responses occur.

Using the right to appraisal

The handout also explains Washington’s right-to-appraisal law, passed last year. Under RCW 48.18.620, every automobile insurance policy with first-party physical damage coverage must include a right to appraisal. The process is aimed at disagreements over actual cash value or the amount of loss.

Each party selects a competent, disinterested appraiser within 10 days. The appraisers assess the actual cash value and amount of loss independently. If they cannot agree, they choose a neutral umpire. If they cannot agree on an umpire, the Washington State Insurance Commissioner appoints one. An agreement reached by two of the three participants—both appraisers, or one appraiser and the umpire—is binding. The appraisal process must be completed within 30 days.

For consumers, appraisal is a defined route to resolve a valuation disagreement, with specified selection steps and a completion period. The revised handout brings that process together with the newer requirements on inspections, written decisions, records and response times, giving drivers a practical set of points to consult as a claim progresses.

Photo courtesy of Nutthaseth Vanchaichana/iStock

Source: Teresa Moss · www.repairerdrivennews.com

In the same chapter